15 Cheddar Cheeses for Every Palate

The best Cheddar cheese is a very popular cheese on the market. Furthermore, it’s a convenient snack; it’s also great for cooking and pairing with different dishes. In addition, it provides calories, protein, calcium, and healthy fats to help you quickly replenish energy for the body.

Moreover, Cheddar cheese is one of many ideal ingredients in place of Fontina ones. They have a wide variety of flavors and are suitable for both adults and children, and it even offers products for vegetarians.

What Is Cheddar Cheese?

Cheddar cheese is made from natural cheese, it is relatively hard, usually has a salty taste, is ivory-white or orange depending on colorants or additives. Furthermore, the name Cheddar is after the name of a village in Somerser, England, where this type of cheese is produced. Moreover, this is a very popular cheese in the UK and the US. It is also the most consumed cheese in the world.

Why Cheddar Cheese Is Popular?

Here are some reasons to clarify why everyone loves cheddar cheese

Make The Food Better

First of all, Cheddar cheese is a great ingredient to add to your dishes. Moreover, it makes your dishes look more attractive and much more delicious. In addition, with each type of food, it brings different experiences.

Health Benefits

Cheddar cheese is also an ideal source to supplement nutrients to the body, such as calcium, protein. Furthermore, many types of cheddar cheese do not contain artificial substances, or substances harmful to health

Great Texture

Compared to other cheeses, Cheddar cheese has an excellent surface texture that makes it easily melt, creating the perfect coating for grilled cheese on toast or create a fabulous sauce.

Diversity

Cheddar cheese products come in a variety of types, including mild, medium, sharp, and extra-sharp. Depending on your interests or the food you want to make with cheese to choose the best types. Therefore, it is a versatile cheese that is popularly used and meets a wide range of customer needs.

People also use Cheddar cheese to make the most delicious string cheese which is suitable for both adults and children. You can use it for cooking, combined with other drinks, even alcohol.

Furthermore, it is suitable for both adults and children. You can use it for cooking, combine with other drinks, even alcohol.

Popular Brands Of The Best Cheddar Cheese

Sargento

Is a famous food production brand in America, especially their cheese products. In addition, it was founded by Leonard Gentine and Joseph Sartori, 1953.

Moreover, the brand’s products come in a wide variety of flavors, sizes, and quality assurance. As a result, Sargento is now one of the country’s largest cheese retailers.

365

Is a reliable producer of cheese products. In addition, the products of this brand are diverse in types and forms of cheese. Furthermore, they are certified vegetarian products.

Kraft

Is a brand that grew from a cheese sales business founded in Chicago in 1903 by James L. Kraft. After years of research and development, Kraft’s cheese products have a fresh taste and can be stored for a long time. Moreover, it is also varied in size, form, and price suitable for all consumers.

Which Are The Best Cheddar Cheeses To Buy?

The best Cheddar cheese brand is Sargento, as it is made from 100% real cheese, and it’s suitable for many different foods. Moreover, this Cheddar cheese comes in sliced form, very easy and convenient to use.

Another best Cheddar cheese you should choose is Tillamook. It is white and extra-sharp cheese with aged over 15 months. Furthermore, you will have delicious homemade sauces with this cheese.

If you want to find the Cheddar cheese for vegetarians, the 365 cheese product is ideal for you. Additionally, it is high in calories and calcium.

It’s time to check out the top 15 best Cheddar cheese to know more about this type of cheese and get more useful information.

• Best Overall: Sargento Pre-Sliced Cheddar Cheese
  “Suitable for many dishes, come in sliced form, good packaging to keep cheese fresh, have a great texture, include vegetable colorants.”
• Best Budget: Annie’s Classic Mild Flavor Cheddar Cheese
  “Made from natural cheese, do not have growth hormones, or artificial flavors, an excellent source of protein and calcium, reasonable price.”
• Best for Sauces: Tillamook Medium Cheddar Cheese
  “Packed in block form, large bag size, great medium cheese, perfect for making home sauces, aged over 60 days.”
• Best for Mac and Cheese: Wisconsin Smooth Texture Cheddar Cheese
  “Have an extra-sharp taste, smooth texture, idea cheese for sandwiches, casseroles, and mac and cheese, not included color additives.”
• Best for Snacks: Easy Cheese 12 Of Pack Cheddar Cheese
  “Come in 8 oz can, pack of 12, easy to add to hotdogs and snacks, convenient to take away, no need to keep in the refrigerator.”
• Best for Nachos: Happy Belly Chopped Form Cheddar Cheese
  “A shredded cheese, no need to slice for using, excellent for salads and nachos, have great guarantee policy.”
• Best for Grilled Cheese: 365 Whole Foods Market Cheddar Cheese
  “The right choice for vegans, no sugar or trans fat, have a yellow color, perfect for grilled cheese, great packaging, need to store in the fridge.”
• Best for Crackers: Kerrygold Aged 2 Years Cheddar Cheese
  “Produced in the family farm, aged over two years, preservative-free, pretty good for pairing with tacos, crackers, and wine.”
• Best for Burgers: Cabot Extra-Sharp White Cheddar Cheese
  “Extra-sharp Cheddar cheese with consistent taste, have classic flavor, do not contain growth hormone and lactose, awsome to add on a juicy burger.”
• Best for Pizza: Tillamook Sharp Shredded Cheddar Cheese
  “Made in the USA, shredded cheese form, fresh flavor, great melting, excellent cheese for pizza, aged over for nine months.”
• Best for Melting: Cracker Barrel No Sugar Cheddar Cheese
  “Provide 110 calories per serving, rich in flavor, smooth in texture, -melting sharp cheddar cheese, easy to add on food.”
• Best for Vegetarians: 365 Shredded Mild Cheddar Cheese
  “Made from cow’s mil without no growth hormones, offer 12 servings per container, certified vegetarians cheese product.”

Cheddar Cheese Comparison Table 2023

Let’s visit the table below illustrates the difference between the top 15 best Cheddar cheese’s main characteristics and figure out that best for you.

My Reviews For The Best Cheddar Cheeses in 2023

Here are the detailed descriptions of the top 15 best Cheddar cheese. Give it a visit to find out the special characteristics of each.

1. Sargento Pre-Sliced Cheddar Cheese

(Best Overall)

The Cheddar cheese is made from 100% natural cheese with pasteurized milk, catalytic enzymes, plant-based colorants, and salt.

Moreover, the product is suitable to add to the appetizer, burger, apple pie, and grilled cheese. In addition, it is packaged in an 8oz bag consisting of 11 individual slices of Sharp Cheddar. Therefore, it is very convenient to use it in small slices.

Besides, the packaging is easy to open and close to keep the cheese fresher for longer.

Furthermore, you can find other Cheddar cheese products of this brand with smoke flavor, Sargento Smoke Flavor Cheddar Cheese, or Sargento Havarti Cheddar Cheese that are perfect for smoked turkey, fresh vegetables, and dried fruit.

Key Features:

• Made from natural cheese
• Have double-zipper closure on the bag to keep the freshness
• Sliced cheese form
• Include 11 slice count

Product Specifications:

Brand	Sargento
Ingredients	Natural cheese, pasteurized milk, plant-based colorants, spices, and enzymes
Item form	Slice (11 slices)
Type	Medium
Serving size	21 grams
Calorie content per serving	80
Protein per serving	5 grams
Size bag	8 oz

2. Annie’s Classic Mild Flavor Cheddar Cheese

(Best Budget)

The Cheddar cheese is made from 100% real cheese, with organic pasta that contains no artificial flavors, preservatives, colorants, or growth hormones like rBST. Therefore, it has absolutely no risk of harm to your health.

In addition, this cheese contains high amounts of calories and protein and does not contain trans fats. Also, it comes in a 6oz box.

Key Features:

• Made with organic pasta
• Without growth hormones
• No preservatives
• Awesome price

Product Specifications:

Brand	Annie’s
Ingredients	Cheddar cheese, organic pasta, corn, acid, milk, whey, salt
Item form	Straws
Type	Mild
Serving size	2.5oz dry mix (71g)
Calorie content per serving	270
Protein per serving	9 grams
Size bag	6oz

Here is a video that shows you the way to make Annie’s mac and cheese. Click the link to know more:

3. Kraft Full-Flavored Sharp Cheddar Cheese

The Cheddar cheese has a rich, full flavor that suits many dishes, helping them smell and taste better.

In addition, the product is made from natural cheese, fresh milk from dairy farms, and annatto to make the color, salt, enzymes, and anti-mold agents.

Furthermore, these cheeses do not contain the hormone rBST, a substance that can lead to the risk of forming tumors or cancer when consumed in high amounts.

Key Features:

• Packed in block form
• Not included hormone rBST
• Made from a brand with many years of experience
• Have 110 calories per 1 oz of cheese

Product Specifications:

Brand	Kraft
Ingredients	Real cheese, fresh milk, annatto, anti-mold substance, salt, and enzymes
Item form	Block
Type	Sharp
Serving size	1oz (28g – 1/8 pkg)
Calorie content per serving	110
Protein per serving	6 gram
Size bag	8 oz

4. Tillamook Medium Cheddar Cheese

(Best for Sauces)

The Cheddar cheese of Tillammok is made entirely of high quality, natural ingredients. In addition, the product is incubated for about 60 days and sold in block form.

Furthermore, its weight is quite large, 2lb, so you can use it for a long time. In addition, these cheeses have a creamy flavor, a blend of sweet and tart to provide the perfect flavor for home sauces.

Also, you can use it for other dishes like bacon or grilled cheese sandwich.

Key Features:

• Give 32 servings
• Medium Cheddar cheese
• Aged more than 60 days
• 2lb bag size

Product Specifications:

Brand	Tillamook
Ingredients	Milk, salt and enzymes, color maker
Item form	Block
Type	Medium
Serving size	28 gram
Calorie content per serving	120
Protein per serving	6 grams
Size bag	2lb

A video that gives you a review about the taste of the block medium Tillamook cheese:

5. Wisconsin Smooth Texture Cheddar Cheese

(Best for Mac and Cheese)

The Wisconsin Cheddar cheese is one of the most popular cheeses on the market. Furthermore, this product has a beautifully smooth texture and sharp taste. In addition, it is a great addition to make your dish more attractive and delicious.

Moreover, it’s perfect for dishes like sandwiches, casseroles, and particularly, mac and cheese. And for the best meal, prepare some complements for your mac and cheese. You can also use your cheese to make these side dishes also.

Also, this Cheddar cheese does not contain any color additives and has been aged for at least one year.

Key Features:

• Aged at least one year
• Smooth and creamy texture
• Come with an ice pack in the box

Product Specifications:

Brand	Wisconsin
Ingredients	Cheese, milk, salt, enzymes
Item form	Block
Type	Extra-sharp
Serving size	28 grams
Calories content per serving	110
Protein per serving	7 grams
Size bag	40oz half loaf

6. Easy Cheese 12 Of Pack Cheddar Cheese

(Best for Snacks)

The Cheddar cheese is packed in small cans with 8oz in volume, and it has a convenient lid to use. Also, it’s very great when serving with hotdogs, snacks.

In addition, when buying the product, you will receive 12 such cans to help you easily store and use for a long time.

Furthermore, it is made from milk, whey, and pureed cheese to give the real taste of Cheddar cheese. Besides, this cheese will provide calcium for you.

Key Features:

• Packed in cans
• Include 12 pack of the item
• Cheese is in creamy form
• Not require refrigeration

Product Specifications:

Brand	Easy cheese
Ingredients	Pure cheese, milk, and whey, sodium, acid, enzymes, annatto
Item form	Cream
Type	Not mentioned
Serving size	2Tbsp (32 grams)
Calorie content per serving	80
Protein per serving	4 grams
Size bag	8oz per 1 can

Let’s watch a video to see the experience when using the Cheddar cheese with cracker:

7. Hickory Farms Smoked Blend Cheddar Cheese

The cheese product is the perfect combination of Cheddar and Swiss cheese. You can also eat it with many different dishes, and you will find that adding cheese to your dish is much better.

Moreover, it has a smoked flavor and comes with a pack of 3.

Key Features:

• The combination of Swiss and Cheddar cheese
• Have smoked flavor
• Not include ice in the box

Product Specifications:

Brand	Hickory Farms
Ingredients	Cheese, cream, milk, sodium, acid, smoking flavor, salt
Item form	Block
Type	Not mentioned
Serving size	1oz (28 grams)
Calory content per serving	90
Protein per serving	6 grams
Size bag	10 oz

8. Happy Belly Chopped Form Cheddar Cheese

(Best for Nachos)

Nacho is a renowned appetizer in Mexican cuisine. And if you want to make your Mexican treats more spectacular, try this product. Happy Belly Cheddar cheese is chopped and packaged in 8-ounce bags, so it is very convenient, and you don’t need to slice it before using it.

In addition, it is a good source of calcium for you with 193mg in the product. Moreover, within a year, if the product does not make you satisfied, you will receive a refund.

Besides, this cheese is excellent for making nachos, salads, and more food.

Key Features:

• Pre-shredded cheese
• Contains high levels of calcium
• Have an excellent refund guarantee

Product Specifications:

Brand	Happy Belly
Ingredients	Cheese, salt, anti-clumping blend, milk, annatto
Item form	Shredded
Type	Sharp
Serving size	¼ cup (28 grams)
Calorie content per serving	110
Protein per serving	6 grams
Size bag	8 oz

9. 365 Whole Foods Market Cheddar Cheese

(Best for Grilled Cheese)

If you are looking for Cheddar cheese for dieters but are so in love with masterly sandwiches, like a grilled cheese sandwich, the 365 brand’s products are a great choice. Furthermore, it contains no sugar or trans fat.

In addition, this cheese is made from the milk of cows that did not receive the rBST hormone. Therefore, it does no harm to your health.

Besides, you should keep the refrigerator’s products to preserve them better and last for a long time.

Key Features:

• Natural and organic product
• The vegan cheese
• Appear in the yellow color

Product Specifications:

Brand	365
Ingredients	Cheese, salt, milk, annatto, enzymes
Item form	Bar
Type	Sharp
Serving size	1oz (28 grams)
Calorie content per serving	110
Protein per serving	7 grams
Size bag	8 oz

10. Kerrygold Aged 2 Years Cheddar Cheese

(Best for Crackers)

The Cheddar cheese by Kerrygold is produced on the family farm from natural ingredients. Furthermore, cheese-making milk is obtained from grass-fed cows, which are not treated with rBST or other growth hormones.

Additionally, the cheese is aged over two years; therefore, it has the delicious taste of perennial Cheddar and is preservative-free.

Moreover, this cheese is great for pairing with wine and crackers or tacos with its rich, nutty flavor.

You can also consider another product of this brand, Kerrygold Unsalted Cheddar Cheese. Besides, it is unsalted cheese, and it has a higher fat content, so great for baked food.

If you like Kerrygold cheese with pre-sliced for convenience and quick preparation of snacks, the product will be the ideal for you, Kerrygold Mild Flavor Cheddar Cheese. It includes ten slices, mild flavor with a hint of prosciutto.

Key Features:

• Take milk from grass-fed cows
• Do not contain any growth hormones
• It’s aged for two years
• Made from natural cheese

Product Specifications:

Brand	Kerrygold
Ingredients	Free-rBST milk, natural cheese, seasonings, enzymes
Item form	Block
Type	Sharp
Serving size	1oz (28 grams)
Calorie content per serving	120
Protein per serving	7 grams
Size bag	7 oz

11. Cabot Extra-Sharp White Cheddar Cheese

(Best for Burgers)

The extra-sharp Cheddar cheese of Cabot has a creamy and consistent flavor. It is aged for a long time to bring out the classic flavor.

Moreover, they can work in place of blue cheese and can melt perfectly on the top of your burger, making them a perfect choice when you don’t have blue cheese on hand.

Furthermore, this cheese product does not contain growth hormones and is lactose-free. Additionally, it is white with a crumbly texture.

It looks great on atop a juicy burger and is suitable for many tempting snacks.

Key Features:

• No have lactose or any hormones
• Cheese is white
• Produced from a farm family
• Not include color maker

Product Specifications:

Brand	Cabot
Ingredients	Fresh milk, cheese, salt, enzymes
Item form	Bar
Type	Extra-sharp
Serving size	1oz (28 grams)
Calorie content per serving	110
Protein per serving	7 grams
Size bag	8 oz

12. Tillamook Sharp Shredded Cheddar Cheese

(Best for Pizza)

Cheddar cheese is made in the USA. Although it is shredded, its flavor is as fresh as block cheese.

Furthermore, its melting level is great, making it suitable for many foods like mac and cheese, tacos, salad, especially pizza. This item is also wonderful to use for making lasagna and its side dishes. Plus, the product is free of trans fats and sugars.

Key Features:

• Made in the USA
• Provide 170mg calcium per container
• It’s aged for over nine months
• Sharp Cheddar cheese

Product Specifications:

Brand	Tillamook
Ingredients	Natamycin, starch, cheese, enzymes, salt
Item form	Shredded
Type	Sharp
Serving size	28 grams
Calorie content per serving	120
Protein per serving	6
Size bag	8 ounce

13. Cracker Barrel No Sugar Cheddar Cheese

(Best for Melting)

The Cheddar cheese by Cracker Barrel is rich in flavor and smooth in texture. Also, it’s well-melting sharp Cheddar, and great when adding on food.

In addition, the product is packaged in 8oz, block form, and each package contains 110 calories and 6 grams of protein. Moreover, it contains no sugar or carbs.

Key Features:

• Include 110 calories per serving
• Smooth texture and taste
• 8 oz per package

Product Specifications:

Brand	Cracker Barrel
Ingredients	Cheese, enzymes, salt, anti-mold element, fresh milk
Item form	Block
Type	Extra-sharp
Serving size	1oz (28 grams)
Calorie content per serving	110
Protein per serving	6 grams
Size bag	8 oz

14. Montchevre Goat Milk Cheddar Cheese

The Cheddar cheese product is made from pasteurized goat milk and has no color, no strong taste, and does not contain artificial substances.

Furthermore, it contains no trans fats or MSG and is entirely safe for health. Moreover, this product is also a source of vitamin A and calcium with 4% and 25%, respectively, for one pack.

Key Features:

• Not included artificial color or flavor
• Do not have preservatives
• Made from white goat milk
• Not included MSG

Product Specifications:

Brand	Montchevre
Ingredients	Fresh goat milk, seasonings, rennet, cheese
Item form	Block
Type	Not mentioned
Serving size	1oz (28 grams)
Calorie content per serving	110
Protein per serving	7 grams
Size bag	8 ounce

15. 365 Shredded Mild Cheddar Cheese

(Best for Vegetarians)

The organic and natural product 365 Cheddar cheese is made from fresh cow’s milk with no growth hormone. Additionally, one pack is divided into 12 servings with 110 calories and 7 grams of protein per serving.

Furthermore, the product is produced in a shredded form, convenient to use, and does not take preparation time. Besides, it is a certified vegetarian cheese product.

Key Features:

• Certified vegetarians cheese product
• Come in shredded form
• Offer 12 servings
• Growth hormones are not included

Product Specifications:

Brand	365
Ingredients	Fresh cow milk, annatto, enzymes, salt, powdered cellulose.
Item form	Shredded
Type	Mild
Serving size	1oz (28 grams)
Calorie content per serving	110
Protein per serving	7 grams
Size bag	12oz

Some Things That Should Keep In Mind When Purchasing The Best Cheddar Cheese

In this part, I give you some guides that you should consider when making decisions on buying cheddar cheese.

Ingredients

The first factor you need to consider is the ingredients, whether they are made from pure cheese or not. Furthermore, you should choose cheese products made from cow’s milk that do not contain growth hormones to avoid harmful health risks. You should also buy cheeses that are free or low in additives, colorants, and gluten.

Nutrition

The nutrition facts of a product are usually printed on the package. You should be interested in calcium, protein, and calcium content. You can also choose products that do not contain sugar or trans fats or look for products for dieting people.

Food Compatibility

In order to buy a suitable cheese, you should also consider what kind of food you want to eat. For example, if you want to make bacon or baked goods, choose cheeses that are highly heat resistant so that they won’t burn. If you want to use cheese as sauces, you can buy one with a good melt and no crumbs.

Form Of Cheese

Cheese in thin slices or shredded form will be convenient to use, saving preparation time. However, they often contain preservatives to prevent clumping.

With block cheese, although you will have to cut it into thin slices or melt it to add to dishes, it usually costs less than pre-cut cheese and contains fewer additives.

Moreover, you can choose straws cheese to add to sauces or fruits easily. It also tastes very good.

Size

The size of the cheese is also a factor need to think. Furthermore, you can choose the size of cheese based on the serving size for adults or children. In addition, it is depending on the frequency of using to choose the appropriate size. You should not store cheese for too long at home as its freshness will decrease or lose its flavor.

FAQs

Let’s read some answers for some questions that are asked frequently to get more useful information when using Cheddar cheese.

My Top Pick

My favorite Cheddar cheese is Easy Cheese 12 Of Pack Cheddar Cheese because it’s very delicious and convenient to use. I can add it for snacks, crackers, or hotdogs. Furthermore, it is still fresh without keeping refrigerated. Moreover, it comes with 12 cans for a long term of use.

Do you like Cheddar cheese? Which Cheddar cheese you think idea for you? Let’s share your choice with me, discuss it together!

Also, I’ll help you find the answers to any related questions about the Cheddar cheese. Therefore, don’t hesitate to ask me!