28+ Potluck Desserts That Steal the Show

Potluck parties are an exciting way to connect people, and potluck desserts are of the utmost importance in that event! On this occasion, people will gather and share the prepared desserts.

When you plan to attend a potluck party soon, I know the dilemma that always comes up with what to cook? But don’t worry because my article has all the recipes you need!

Make Your Guests Satisfy With 29 Fascinating Potluck Desserts!

Get everyone hooked for a second with these 29 delicious and easy-to-make recipes. Pick now your favorite and try it at your next potluck party!

Cookie And Brownie

1. Chocolate Chip Cookies
2. Oreo Cookie Balls
3. Amish Sugar Cookies
4. Kitchen Sink Cookies
5. Cookies and Cream Brownies
6. Peanut Butter Cookie Bars
7. Monster Magic Cookie Bars
8. Chocolate Crinkle Cookies
9. Fudge-Topped Brownies

Cakes

10. Louisiana Crunch Cake
11. Reese’s Peanut Butter Poke Cake
12. Coconut Carrot Cake Cupcakes
13. Pear Bundt Cake
14. Cherry Cheesecake Cupcakes
15. Jelly Donut
16. Cranberry Cheesecake
17. Pineapple Sheet Cake

Others

18. Ambrosia Fruit Salad
19. Banana Bars
20. Magic Bars
21. Banana Oat Bars
22. Rice Krispie Treats
23. Scotcheroos
24. Cherry Chewbilees
25. Rainbow Jello Cubes
26. Chocolate Pudding Pizza
27. Chocolate Peanut Clusters
28. Peanut Butter Cups
29. Pecan Cheesecake Squares

You Must Try 29 Flavorful Potluck Desserts Below As Soon As Possible!

If you want to bring a unique dessert to your upcoming potluck party, here are the best ideas you must know. Check out the recipes and win over your friends with your culinary skills!

Surprise Everyone With 9 Awesome Cookie and Brownie

Cookies and brownies are almost everyone’s favorite choices. So why not try using this ingredient in the most unique and creative desserts recipe? See below!

1. Chocolate Chip Cookies

This is an ideal summer cookie recipe that you can make quickly for your potluck party. Chocolate chip cookies have an eye-catching appearance, moderate sweetness and buttery aroma.

Once baked, these chocolate chip cookies have a nice brown color. You will taste the bittersweet and rich flavor of chocolate. This dessert is quite suitable for weekend get-togethers with family and friends.

One more interesting characteristic: these cookies are crunchy on the outside and ooey gooey  on the inside. Note, these cookies will be soft after baking. It would be best if you let them cool. In this way, the outside will be more crispy.

The best chocolate chip cookie recipe to make sure you will succeed right at the first time! You can see this video to know more:

2. Oreo Cookie Balls

If you need a dessert with a reasonably bite-sized appearance, this is what you are looking for. The rich and creamy combination of oreo grated into cream cheese is really fabulous and sure to delight you.

This is my whole family’s favorite buttery taste and brittle texture. It is suitable for holidays’ potlucks like Thanksgiving, Christmas, etc. I thought it would be fun to make these oreo cookie balls. Even your children will also enjoy participating. Discover now!

3. Amish Sugar Cookies

If you are a nostalgic person, you will love this old-fashioned Amish sugar cookie. Maybe your grandma used to make them for you too!

These are sugared cookies with a soft and moist texture. It’s great because you can make use of the ingredients available to do this recipe, such as buttermilk or regular milk with a bit of flour already in the cupboard.

4. Kitchen Sink Cookies

Do you like cookies that are soft and chewy? Kitchen sink cookies will make you excited with many interesting ingredients. The signature chocolate flavor blends well with the cookies, and everything will make you feel delighted.

The fascinating thing here is that this cookie filling includes both savory and sweet components. The pretzels and potato chips combined with bittersweet chocolate chips and toffee make a whole new dining experience.

You can even add more sweet and savory fillings to pack the cookies until they can’t hold anymore to satisfy your eating passion.

Try now your kitchen sink cookies with this detailed recipe and tutorial!

5. Cookies And Cream Brownies

These special brownies are made of yummy cookies mixed with cream, so they are called cookie and cream brownies. These brownies are characterized by a flavorsome soft crust interspersed with silky buttercream.

They have a bittersweet chocolate flavor and a tangy butter scent that everyone loves, even the children. This is also an incredible simple potluck recipe to make sure you will succeed right the first time. Come to the kitchen with me now!

6. Peanut Butter Cookie Bars

Peanut butter cookie bar is one of the classic and trendy choices. The well-loved nut butter variety forms attractive crunchy bars with its moderate fatty taste.

These cookies are easy to eat and provide a lot of energy. When the two are combined together into these bars, you will find them excellent with an alluring sugared and nutty taste. These interesting bars go perfectly with a cup of tea.

7. Monster Magic Cookie Bars

The unique combination of chocolate chips, and crushed graham crackers, especially the colorful M&M candies makes these bars extremely toothsome and funny to eat.

That makes these magic cookie bars a favorite of many people, especially children. About the texture, they are a bit thicker than graham cakes.

In addition, chocolate and oat absorb the sugariness of sweetened condensed milk, creating a balanced taste for this cookie bar. Despite the complete separation of each layer, they still perfectly blend together, creating the ideal crunchy texture while eating.

8. Chocolate Crinkle Cookies

Not just for Christmas, these chocolate crinkle cookies are a great classic dessert for any potluck party. They are fun to do with easy steps.

With each bite, you will experience two layers of texture: a crunchy crust on the outside and an ultra-soft inside like texture of brownie. Everything blends for a stimulating whole.

9. Fudge-Topped Brownies

The classic chocolate brownie base will become even more appealing with a rich fudge-topping layer on top. Use butter or margarine for a buttery flavor that blends into every bite.

The vanilla scent mingles with the signature flavors of milk and eggs that blend wonderfully with bittersweet cocoa powder. Mix in a little chopped nuts for an unforgettable eating experience.

Bring 8 Fantastic Cake Into Your Potluck Party:

Something unique is definitely what you need for your upcoming potluck party! Consider now these soft and sweet cake desserts! All are state-of-the-art to stand out at your party!

10. Louisiana Crunch Cake

As its name suggests, Louisiana cake has a spongy texture and amazing aroma. They look attractive with the light golden color. You will feel the soft and moist bite with a combination of fragrant vanilla.

The light sugar glaze on top of the cake provides a moderate sweetness. The top is also covered with a fascinating layer of shredded coconut creating an even more exciting experience.

11. Reese’s Peanut Butter Poke Cake

You need to try this fascinating poke cake! It is great for those who love the taste of peanut butter. The combination of huge creamy cheese coating and sticky chocolate create an overall paradise.

The scent of milk and vanilla spreads everywhere in the space with this poke cake. The rich but not too sweet flavor will encourage everyone to eat to the last bite without feeling guilty. It is thanks to the perfect balance between ingredients.

If you love this treat, the chances are that you’ll love Samoan poke cake as well. That’s right, poke cake is also a popular dish you can find in Samoa. And like this recipe I’m offering you, Samoan poke cake is also a burst of fudgy flavors that will get you addicted.

12. Coconut Carrot Cake Cupcakes

A dinner party will be warm with coconut carrot cupcakes and the smelled seasoning aroma. Feel the super soft cupcakes on the tip of your tongue with the sweetness of brown sugar and interesting coconut crumbs.

What makes these cupcakes special is the moisture. This is created by deeply penetrating spices such as Greek yogurt and eggs. You can double the wonderful flavor with a silky smooth cheese frosting on top.

13. Pear Bundt Cake

Awaken your taste buds with this aromatic dessert made from pears. It’s the irresistible charm of rosemary that pervades your kitchen.

The cake base has an absolutely passionate honeyed taste and a light sweet essence of pear. Once out of the oven, pear bundt cake has a beautiful golden brown color that will impress anyone.

14. Cherry Cheesecake Cupcakes

Make this lovely sweet treat for your cherry-loving guests that will come to the upcoming potluck party. You can make use of finely ground graham crackers, so your cheesecake will have an engaging texture.

The soft and fatty cream cheese coating will make the little cupcakes more flavorful. Double filling of sweet fresh cherry pie to add a pleasant little surprise inside for your dear guests.

15. Jelly Donut

Jelly donuts can absolutely be made at home and still taste just as good as the bakery! The sugar-coated donuts are as light as the air that will crunch in your mouth with every bite.

The taste of butter blends with milk and eggs to create a fatty and aromatic crust. Inside is your favorite jam for filling. These tasty donuts will quickly run out on your table.

16. Cranberry Cheesecake

Cranberry cheesecake will make everyone admire its outstanding appearance. The characteristic sweet red sugared crust of cranberries followed by a layer of soft orange cheese dip.

The slightly sour flavor mixed with the creamy taste will be hard to refuse. The faint aroma of cinnamon and nutmeg also add more fragrant to this. It all blends in every slice of the cake and melts in your mouth!

17. Pineapple Sheet Cake

With a soft spongy texture, combined with the particular sweet taste of pineapple, this sheet cake is definitely a must-try dessert that even the most discerning diners will love.

This pineapple cake combines a lot of exciting components with thick cream cheese layers on top. You will notice the taste of eggs mixed with vanilla and butter. You can store this cake in the refrigerator for 1 week and it still remains flavorful. 

12 Other Delicious Desserts to Boost Your Guests’ Taste:

These 12 remaining great recipes can cater to even the discerning crowd in the epic potluck feast. Everyone will have to compliment you when these items are displayed on the table!

18. Ambrosia Fruit Salad

Ambrosia is a beautiful and flavorful dessert from Brazil with eye-catching colors. This recipe is a variation based on the traditional salad for your next potluck.

You will get to taste various combinations of chopped fruits mixed together. The sour and sugary tropical fruits are complete with a bit of creamy and smooth Cool Whip.

Indeed, Ambrosia salad truly deserves its “food for the gods” name. Remember to chill it for a few hours or overnight before serving.

19. Banana Bars

If you have ripe bananas at home, try to make these interesting sweets with your bananas. These bars’ base is not crispy yet a bit soft and moist, creating a comfortable eating experience. You can feel the vanilla and butter flavor mixed well in every bite.

Overall is even more engrossing with the creamy cream cheese frosting on top blending excellently with the sweet banana taste. The crunchy walnuts intermingle with the banana generating a fascinating texture.

20. Magic Bars

Why is this dessert called a magic bar? Because the layers of ingredients overlap and create a taste like magic! Rich sweet blend created with chocolate, butterscotch, coconut, and nuts.

Moreover, these bars are easy to make and do not take up your time. This lovely dessert doesn’t even require any flour yet still tastes beautiful in your mouth. Just spread the ingredients you like and bake quickly. Enjoy!

21. Banana Oat Bars

You can find banana oat bars in diet menus for losing weight. Oats are one of the healthiest cereals. When combined with bananas – another nutrient-rich fruit, it will definitely be an excellent choice for anyone.

The combination of these two ingredients creates stunning crispy bars. You cannot deny the awesome taste and moistness. The banana’s light sweetness and delicate texture balance with the crunchiness of the baked oat, making everything absolutely succulent!

Moreover, banana oat bars also provide many essential minerals along with large amounts of soluble fiber. This is absolutely an effective dessert to serve for the best party table. 

22. Rice Krispie Treats

The crispy texture and sweet flavor characterize Krispie rice treats. The plus point is that when making rice Krispie treats at home, you can adjust the amount of sugar accordingly, so it will easily fit your taste.

Just go through a few steps, and you will find that making them is not only not complicated but also simple beyond your imagination. Let’s enjoy these treats together!

23. Scotcheroos

You can’t refuse these scotcheroos once you know them! Scotcheroos will be the favorite dessert once everyone has enjoyed it.

Every bite will be incredible with the crunchiness of Krispies rice, the smoothness of peanut butter, the distinctive flavor of chocolate, and the butteriness of butterscotch. They are full of flavor with a delightful texture.

This recipe is also made quickly with simple ingredients, which are almost always available in the kitchen cupboard, so you can start making them any time. You can invite your kids to do the same because it’s actually not that difficult at all!

This tasty and chewy homemade scotcheroo will bring everyone the best experience! You can see this video to know more:

24. Cherry Chewbilees

The summer party will be great if there are cherry chewbilees to enjoy. Of course, the chewbilees will make you swoon. Even just looking at its striking appearance makes your mouth water.

The nutty flavors of the nuts and coconut are balanced well with the cherry pie filling  and the rich cream cheese. It is also effortless to do.

You can keep it in the fridge for a long time without fear of spoiling. A little baking time, and you will have this wonderful dessert for the whole season!

25. Rainbow Jello Cubes

Everyone will be captivated by a colorful dessert. Try attracting your guests with these rainbow jello cubes! Multiple layers of vibrant colors layered on top of each other create a delightful dining experience.

Moreover, you can cut each jello into your favorite shape: round, square, star, flower, etc. Vary the amount of condensed milk depending on how sweet you want your food that begins with “J” to be. The cool soft rainbow will leave your mouth full!

26. Chocolate Pudding Pizza

Why not create a unique pizza filled with mouth-watering chocolate? Here is an easy and fun potluck recipe for you to experiment with over the weekend. Surely no one can resist!

This chocolate pudding pizza includes many layers of flavors stacked on top of each other, creating an attractive whole! It has the taste of fatty peanut butter and creamy cream cheese.

27. Chocolate Peanut Clusters

Surely, anyone will love chocolate and peanuts that go hand in hand. They taste scrumptious, and the ingredients are super easy to find. This will be one of the most accessible chocolate clusters to make ever!

​​The absolute ingredients blend in a crunchy texture of peanut and chewy chocolate. And this is a big plus: you can use any chocolate flavor you crave, whether it’s dark, milky, or semi-sweet. All are great!

These super easy chocolate peanut clusters are  the perfect idea! You can see this video to know more:

28. Peanut Butter Cups

Peanut butter cups are made from hot chocolate and peanut butter. It is pretty popular in many countries for potluck parties. Why not try it at the next event?

These cups, when finished, will have a nutty taste from peanut butter with a little bittersweet chocolate. The texture is both soft and chewy. When biting it, the chocolate and peanut butter melt on the tip of the tongue. It is desirable!

You can use any type like milk or dark chocolate for the chocolate layer or mix them, depending on your taste. Peanut butter cups are also straightforward to store, just put them in a container with a lid and freeze them to keep for about 2 to 3 days.

29. Pecan Cheesecake Squares

There are always sweet teeth in the party, and this recipe will satisfy them! The perfect dessert is a combination of crunchy pecans on a silky cheesecake background and shortbread cut into bite-sized squares.

Each bite is extremely scrumptious with a fascinating aroma mixed with three layers of interesting ingredients. This sweet recipe is easy to make and your oven will do almost anything.

Let’s Make Your Potluck Party Gorgeous!

It is marvellous to have the outstanding potluck dessert on your hand when all the guests gather at the table. So, choose some excellent choices from my list above and prepare for your next party!

Now, let’s plan to throw a party together without anyone stressing about the preparation time with these wonderful desserts available! Finally, enjoy and share my post if you love it!